Getting in Front of It – GLD

One group of people that’s even more fanatical than the Goldman Sachs conspiracy theorists are the Goldbugs. As I read David Einhorn’s (Greenlight Capital) quarterly letter last night, one thing jumped out at me:

“We made a couple of modest changes to our macro hedges. First, after extensive investigation, we switched our entire GLD exchange traded fund position into physical gold. At a minimum this will provide some savings as the costs of storing gold are less than the fees on GLD.”

Now, I happen to believe in GLD as a product. I have read the prospectus multiple times, which states that the GLD owns physical gold bullion – not gold futures or other paper versions of gold. GLD shares can actually be redeemed for physical gold bullion (if you have enough shares). This doesn’t stop the Goldbugs from trumpeting about how the GLD is NOT the same as gold, and that if you really want to own gold, you should buy bullion instead. Well, GLD is not gold – it’s a share in a trust that owns gold, but the difference is that I actually believe that the trust owns the gold, while some Goldbugs think the whole thing is a giant scam.

Anyway, I’m CERTAIN that in the coming days, you’ll be able to find some rantings about how Einhorn’s “extensive investigation” which resulted in him swapping out of GLD and into bullion is evidence that there are problems with GLD. Look – I cannot guarantee to you that the GLD is a perfect product – I have not seen and audited the gold in their vault (although I am close to someone who works intimately with the GLD trust, and who offered me exactly such an opportunity, should I make it to London in the near future). However, Einhorn explained one reason for the switch – cost. He’s got a sizable position, and the means to store physical gold, so he holds the cheaper version.

Also, I could interpret this as a validation of GLD. Although I don’t know how Einhorn swapped his GLD for physical bullion – I’d be willing to bet he simple “redeemed” the GLD shares he had with the trust, and took delivery of gold bullion. This is great news for those who fear that the GLD is a paper pyramid – that Einhorn was able to do exactly what he was supposed to do – that GLD and gold are essentially fungible. Again, I can’t be sure that’s what Einhorn did, and if anyone has any evidence or inkling that he actually sold his GLD position and bought physical bullion, I’d LOVE to hear about it, as that would nullify my whole point.

We could also draw the conclusion that perhaps Einhorn plans to hold this position for a longer period of time – although, since GLD and gold are fungible, he could easily liquidate his position by shorting GLD and creating shares of the ETF with the trust to close out his position – relax, it’s not as confusing as it sounds – you can take your GLD and give them to the trust in exchange for gold bars, or you can take your gold bars (redeem) and give them to the trust in exchange for GLD (create). In other words, the GLD is just a more liquid way for the average person (or the professional hedge fund manager) to trade gold.

-KD

full disclosure: long GLD and SLV

and note to Goldbugs: PLEASE do not leave me comments saying that the GLD is fraudulent because it can be shorted – it’s a false logic argument, and it’s incorrect.

Kid Dynamite is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. If you click on my Amazon.com links and buy anything, even something other than the product advertised, I earn a small commission, yet you don't pay any extra. Thank you for your support.

The information in this blog post represents my own opinions and does not contain a recommendation for any particular security or investment. I or my affiliates may hold positions or other interests in securities mentioned in the Blog, please see my Disclaimer page for my full disclaimer.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Kiddynamitesworld Blog